After Yuri and Natsuki leave the room, Sayori talks to the protagonist but revealingly the player. She comments how she is now club president, and therefore, she knows everything that has happened. Sayori then decides to pick up where Monika has left off in Act 3, but Monika is revealed to not be quite gone and deletes Sayori before she can do anything else.
Monika concludes that there is no happiness in the Literature Club, primarily because one has to be president, and being one gives the character a revelation that drives them to insanity. Monika then decides to erase the whole game, but before she does so, she presents the player a song she saved called "Your Reality." It plays as the credits roll until the final end screen that depends on what the player has done before Sayori's suicide.
- If the player did not save-scum throughout the game, the CGs will be deleted in the credits sequence. The unseen CGs will appear in the credits with a grey filter. The note left behind is Monika's notice that the Literature Club has been disbanded and how she still loves everyone.
- If the player save-scummed and looked at all the 10 CGs, Sayori won't attempt to continue where Monika had left off in Act 3 but rather thanks the player for being thoughtful about making everyone happy. The credits will appear, but this time the CGs won't be deleted. The note left behind is a "thank you" message from the developer.
Afterwards, any interaction with the game will pop up an error message prompting the player to reinstall the game in order to play again. An offline alternative is to delete "firstrun," which allows the player to perform a hard reset.
- If the player restores Monika's character file after starting a new game, it will prompt a message saying, "Please stop playing with my heart. I don't want to come back," and it will delete the character file. If the player restores Monika's character file a second time, Monika will delete the file again without notifying the player.